نمونه رایتینگ آیلتس به همراه پاسخ موضوع تاریخ هنر معماری ایران

It is better to learn the way people lived in the world through films

📌 It is better to learn the way people lived in the world through films and video records than written documents.

To what extent do you agree or disagree?

The quest to understand historical lifestyles is a fascinating endeavour, and in the modern era, we are presented with a choice between visual media like films and video records, and traditional written documents. While I acknowledge the powerful impact of audiovisual materials, I firmly disagree that they are a superior source of knowledge compared to written records.

Proponents of visual media argue that films and video footage offer an immersive and accessible gateway into the past. They can vividly recreate the sights, sounds, and atmosphere of a bygone era, making history feel immediate and tangible, especially for those who find written texts dry or challenging. For periods where actual video records exist, such as from the late 19th century onwards, we gain an unmediated view of events, from the fashion and body language of people to the actual conditions on a battlefield or a city street. This visceral connection can spark a deep emotional engagement that parchment and ink may struggle to evoke.

However, the fundamental limitation of visual records is their inherent subjectivity and potential lack of depth. A documentary film is an edited interpretation, and a historical drama is often a fictionalised account prioritising narrative over factual accuracy. Written documents, on the other hand, provide the foundational bedrock of historical understanding. They offer the nuanced, first-hand perspectives found in diaries, letters, and legal contracts, which reveal the complex motivations, thoughts, and economic realities of individuals. Furthermore, for the vast expanse of human history predating the invention of the camera, written records are our only direct window into the minds of our ancestors. We could never understand the philosophical debates of Ancient Greece or the administrative intricacies of the Roman Empire through film alone; it is through their texts that these civilisations continue to speak to us.

In conclusion, while films and video records are invaluable tools for engaging a broad audience and providing a sensory-rich depiction of more recent history, they should be seen as a complement to, rather than a replacement for, written documents. The depth, detail, and direct access to the human thought provided by texts are irreplaceable. Therefore, I strongly disagree that visual media offer a better way to learn about how people lived; instead, a holistic approach that critically evaluates both sources is the most reliable path to historical understanding.


More 2025 IELTS Essays for You

تصحیح رایگان رایتینگ شما در کانال تلگرام ما

نوشته‌ای مرتبط

پاسخی بگذارید

نشانی ایمیل شما منتشر نخواهد شد. بخش‌های موردنیاز علامت‌گذاری شده‌اند *